Business Information
As featured on One Bite with Dave Portnoy, Islamorada Pizza Co. brings you a true slice of paradise with hot, handcrafted pizzas served whole or by the slice. This local favorite in Islamorada offers a relaxed, family-friendly atmosphere with indoor dining, spacious front and back patios, and a convenient pick-up window perfect for grabbing a fresh pie to enjoy on the beach or back at the resort. Known for flavorful crusts, quality ingredients, and fast, friendly service, it’s a go-to spot for anyone exploring restaurants in Islamorada. Open daily!

Pepperoni and beef Pizza from Islamorada Pizza Co., a pizza restaurant in Islamorada

Cheesy Breadsticks Ranch Dusted, Red Sauce

Islamorada, Meat Lovers Pizza & Garden Pizza Lunch, Dinner

Garden Pizza White Sauce, Mozzarella, Bell Pepper, Red Onion, Spinach, Artichoke, Mushroom, Feta, Basil Pesto

Guava & Cream Cheese Pie, Pineapple, Raw Sugar, Toasted Coconut

Nonna's Meatballs House Red Sauce, Ricotta, Parmesan, Basil, Garlic Knots

Classic Cheese Pizza, Red Sauce, Mozzarella

Calzo-Nadas Spanakopita | Cheesy Pepperoni | Buffalo Chicken Calzone

Sausage & Peppers Pizza Red Sauce, Roasted Bell Peppers, Red Onion, Oregano, Basil

Garden Pizza White Sauce, Mozzarella, Bell Pepper, Red Onion, Spinach, Artichoke, Mushroom, Feta, Basil Pesto

Cheesy Breadsticks from Islamorada Pizza Co., a pizza restaurant in Islamorada

Interior of a pizza restaurant in Islamorada, Florida Keys

Ranch Dusted, Red Sauce breadsticks at Islamorada Pizza Co.

Red Sauce, Mozzarella, Basil Pesto pizza at islamorada pizza co

Red Sauce, Pepperoni Cups, Mozzarella, Hot Honey pizza at Islamorada Pizza Co.

Exterior of Islamorada Pizza Co. Restaurant in Islamorada

Red Sauce, Pepperoni Cups, Mozzarella, Hot Honey and White Sauce, Mozzarella, Bell Pepper, Red Onion, Spinach, Artichoke, Mushroom, Feta, Basil Pesto

Spanakopita | Cheesy Pepperoni | Buffalo Chicken Calzone

Herbed Garlic Knots, Marinara Sauce, Parmesan, Oven-Baked Wings Garlic & Parmesan Classic Buffalo Honey BBQ House-Made Ranch

Pizza Pies at Islamorada Pizza Co. restaurant in Islamorada

Opening Times
Mon 4pm-9pm, Tue-Wed Closed, Thu-Sun 4pm-9pm

Payment Methods Accepted
American Express, Discover, MasterCard, Visa

Additional Websites

https://www.islamoradapizzaco.com/menus/

order

https://www.ubereats.com/store/islamorada-pizza-co-84341-overseas-highway/LNYIhWGPQmq8M7Cj87Bmdw?srsltid=AfmBOorIKY2ZDEvVNZEDFoFgaiY2PrCIJdIF-D4Vnj2qzCApLw5P9UO_

Email Addresses
hello@islamoradapizzaco.com

Languages:
en

Map location Select here to view map

Editing or updating this listing

Update your details here if you are unaware of any log-in information for this listing.

Disclaimer

Opinions expressed within reviews are those of the individual author and are not the views or opinions of Lowi Ltd, My Local Services or any of its employees.

If you have an issue with any review comments then please fill in the review issue form and include as much detail as possible.

Incorrect data:
If you want to report incorrect information on this web page, then please contact us and outline the issue. We aim to resolve most problems within one business day.